A brief history of person-first and identity-first language

Person-first language began as a well-meant reform. The identity-first countermovement grew from disabled people themselves. Here is how both took shape, and where the debate stands today.

Restored page.

This address was part of the original Identity-First Autistic campaign site (2016). The original page traced person-first language back to US advocacy groups in the late 1980s, described the National Federation of the Blind's 1993 resolution and the Deaf community's rejection of person-first terms, and argued that identity-first language was the majority preference among autistic people. The text below is a new, updated version written by the site’s current editors. How this site relates to the original campaign.

Few debates about words have lasted as long, or mattered as much to the people being described, as the argument over “person with a disability” versus “disabled person.” This page traces how person-first language (PFL) became the professional standard in the United States, why several disability communities pushed back with identity-first language (IFL), and what style guides and research say today. Although this site focuses on autism, the history is shared across disability communities, so it should be useful to anyone writing or thinking about disability language in general.

Before the debate: the language PFL replaced

For much of the twentieth century, official and everyday language about disability was blunt and often dehumanizing. People were described as “the handicapped,” “cripples,” “invalids,” or by diagnostic labels used as nouns. Institutions, laws, and charities used these terms freely, and they usually carried an assumption that a disabled life was a lesser or tragic one.

Disability rights movements of the 1960s and 1970s challenged both the treatment of disabled people and the words used about them. Some of the earliest arguments for putting the person before the condition came from rehabilitation psychology, a field that wanted clinicians to see clients as whole people rather than as diagnoses. As Dunn and Andrews (2015) describe in their review for psychologists, this “person first” principle grew out of a sincere effort to reduce stigma.

How person-first language became the rule

Self-advocacy groups also played a part. People with intellectual disabilities organizing in the 1970s used the message that they were people first, a direct response to being reduced to labels. Other movements made similar moves around the same period; for example, AIDS activists in the early 1980s insisted on being called “people with AIDS” rather than “victims.”

The specific phrase “people-first language” is commonly dated to the late 1980s, when US advocacy organizations began recommending it explicitly. The exact first use is hard to pin down, and different sources give different dates, so it is safest to say the practice became widespread from the late 1980s through the 1990s.

Several developments helped make it the norm:

  • Federal law. The Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 speaks of “individuals with disabilities,” and in the same year the main US special education law was renamed the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. Legal language of this kind shaped how agencies, schools, and service providers wrote.
  • Professional style guides. Academic and clinical style manuals, including those of the American Psychological Association, recommended or required person-first constructions for years. Gernsbacher (2017) notes that style guides from both the American Psychological and American Psychiatric Associations prescribed person-first language in scholarly writing.
  • Training and education. Teachers, nurses, social workers, and journalists learned PFL as the respectful default, often in diversity or sensitivity training. For many professionals it became the only “correct” option they had ever been taught.

The intention was good: to remind people that a disabled person is a person, not a condition. The problem, as critics would point out, was that the rule was largely set by professionals and non-disabled allies, and it was applied to communities who had not asked for it.

The countermovement: identity-first language

Identity-first language puts the disability or identity first, as an adjective: “disabled person,” “blind woman,” “autistic child.” It treats the characteristic as a neutral or even valued part of who someone is, the way we say “left-handed person” or “Jewish teacher.” The countermovement did not begin in one place. Several communities reached similar conclusions independently.

The National Federation of the Blind (1993)

One of the clearest early statements came from the National Federation of the Blind (NFB), the largest US organization of blind people. At its 1993 national convention, the NFB adopted Resolution 93-01, which rejected the idea that the word “person” must always come before “blind.” The resolution called that requirement “totally unacceptable and pernicious,” arguing that the euphemism was defensive and implied shame rather than equality.

The resolution was introduced alongside an essay by longtime NFB leader Kenneth Jernigan, “The Pitfalls of Political Correctness: Euphemisms Excoriated,” first published in the Federation’s Braille Monitor in August 1993 and reprinted with the resolution in March 2009. Jernigan’s core argument was that changing the words does not change underlying attitudes, and that awkward circumlocutions can make blind people seem fragile. The NFB still describes its members as “blind people.”

Deaf culture and the capital D

Deaf communities had been developing their own vocabulary for some time. In 1972 the linguist James Woodward proposed a written convention that is still widely used: lowercase “deaf” for the audiological condition, and capitalized “Deaf” for people who share a culture and a sign language (Woodward, 1972). In this framing, being Deaf is a linguistic and cultural identity, much like being a member of any other language community.

For many Deaf people, “person with deafness” or “person with hearing loss” misses the point entirely. It describes a medical deficit, when the person may understand themselves primarily as part of a cultural minority. “Deaf person” or simply “Deaf” is the common preference, though individuals vary, and some people who lose hearing later in life prefer other terms.

Autistic self-advocates

Autistic people began organizing online in the 1990s, and language was an early topic. In 1999, autistic advocate Jim Sinclair wrote a short essay, Why I dislike “person first” language, which became one of the most widely circulated texts on the subject. Sinclair made three points: autism cannot be separated from the person; central characteristics are normally described with adjectives (we say “Catholic” or “male,” not “person with Catholicism”); and people only insist on separating a trait from a person when they believe the trait is bad.

The Autistic Self Advocacy Network (ASAN), founded in 2006, adopted identity-first language as its house style. Its explainer on identity-first language, originally written by autistic activist Lydia X. Z. Brown in 2011, acknowledges that PFL was designed to affirm personhood but argues that, for autism, it implies the condition is something negative to be held at arm’s length. The essay also respects that individuals may choose their own terms.

The original Identity-First Autistic campaign, launched by autistic people in 2016, belonged to this tradition. You can read more about how autistic people have embraced the word in Reclaiming “autistic”.

Why the communities objected

Across blind, Deaf, and autistic communities, the objections to mandatory PFL tend to fall into a few themes:

  1. It implies the characteristic is shameful. We rarely use person-first constructions for neutral or positive traits. Requiring them for disability can signal that disability is uniquely bad.
  2. It separates people from part of their identity. For people who experience their disability as shaping how they think, perceive, or communicate, “with” sounds like an accessory.
  3. It was imposed rather than chosen. Many disabled people felt the rule was made about them without them.
  4. It can be clumsy. Long constructions such as “individuals with visual impairments” can make writing harder to read and can draw extra attention to the very thing they are meant to downplay.

It is important to add that supporters of PFL also have reasons, and that some disabled people genuinely prefer it. Our explainer on identity-first vs person-first language sets out both sides fairly.

Research and style guides catch up

Evidence on preferences

From the mid-2010s, researchers began asking autistic people directly. A large UK survey by Kenny et al. (2016) found that “autistic” was endorsed by a large share of autistic adults, family members, and parents, but by considerably fewer professionals, while “person with autism” was endorsed by almost half of professionals. The authors concluded that no single term was universally accepted.

Later studies found similar patterns:

  • In a US survey of 728 autism stakeholders, Taboas et al. (2023) found that 87% of autistic adults preferred identity-first language for themselves, while 13% preferred person-first language. Professionals were more likely to use and prefer PFL.
  • A global survey of 654 English-speaking autistic adults by Keating et al. (2023) found that “autistic person” and “is autistic” were consistently among the most favored terms across countries, while also emphasizing that there is no universally accepted way to talk about autism and that personal preference should be respected.

Changes in research and professional writing

Gernsbacher (2017) analyzed scholarly writing and found that person-first language was used more often for children with disabilities than for children without them, and most often for the most stigmatized conditions. She argued this pattern may accentuate stigma rather than reduce it.

Bottema-Beutel et al. (2021) drew on autistic scholarship to show how language in autism research can reflect ableist assumptions, and offered researchers concrete alternatives. Responding to a 2020 “Ask the Editor” article on how researchers should talk about autism, Botha, Hanlon, and Williams (2023) argued that language in research has real consequences for autistic people, and that the debate should center on their autonomy and right to self-determination.

Style guides have shifted too. The current APA Style guidance on disability, which reflects the 7th edition of the APA Publication Manual (2020), treats both person-first and identity-first language as acceptable and says that a group’s or individual’s expressed preference should take priority. Journalism guidance has followed a similar path: the National Center on Disability and Journalism style guide advises asking people how they want to be described and notes that identity-first language is strongly preferred in Deaf and autistic communities.

Where things stand now

Today, neither form is universally “correct.” The broad picture is:

  • Many autistic, blind, and Deaf people prefer identity-first language, and many disabled people more generally use “disabled person” with pride.
  • Some disabled people, including some autistic people, prefer person-first language, and that choice deserves equal respect.
  • Many professionals and parents still default to PFL, often because it is what they were taught.
  • Major style guides now allow both and defer to the preferences of the people being described.

This site uses identity-first language by default because it is the documented preference of most autistic adults surveyed, but we always defer to an individual’s own choice. If you are unsure what someone prefers, see our guide on how to ask about language preferences. For why these choices matter beyond politeness, read Why language matters, and for the wider framework behind identity-first thinking, see the social model of disability.

About this page

This web address was originally part of the Identity-First Autistic campaign site, created by autistic people in 2016. The original page gave a short history of person-first language, dating it to US advocacy groups in the late 1980s, and described the National Federation of the Blind’s 1993 resolution and the Deaf community’s rejection of person-first terms. It argued that PFL, despite good intentions, implied that disability was something to be ashamed of, and that identity-first language was the majority preference among autistic people.

What you are reading now is a rewritten and expanded version, published by the site’s current, independent editors in November 2026. It is not the work of the original campaign’s authors. We have added newer research and style-guide changes, and we have checked sources where we could.

Sources and further reading

Spotted an error or outdated source? Send a correction. Read our editorial standards.